Chief Justice Rehnquist passes away at home; prepare for the worst of American politics

Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist, who was Chief Justice for the last 18 years of his 33 year career on the High Court died at his home in Virginia on Saturday night.

Justice Rehnquist had been battling thyroid cancer which although quite beatable for a young person is often fatal for the elderly.

That this is a huge loss for the Court and the country goes without saying.

The political implications of this situation, having two Supreme Court vacancies simultaneously, will whip radicals (environmental, racial, sexual, economic) and collectivists of all sorts into a frenzy of paranoia which will make the Roberts process so far look positively tame. It might even make what happened to Robert Bork look civilized.

[Ironically, the last time there were two vacancies at the same time were in 1971, and Justice Rehnquist was one of the Judges appointed (by President Nixon) to fill one of those vacancies.]

In order to prevent such a fiasco (which the Democrats probably want as fund-raising motivation), President Bush should refuse to nominate someone to fill the Chief Justice position until Judge Roberts is confirmed.

The other reason to have some hope that the process will not become a national embarrassment is that Justice Rehnquist was such a conservative Judge. Even more than with Justice O'Connor, this means that Bush's likely very conservative choice to fill the Rehnquist vacancy will have little effect on the net balance on the court. If it were Justice Stevens or Ginsburg who were being replaced, the fight would probably be substantially more brutal than replacing Justice Rehnquist will be.

Yet, I do not see much chance of Senators Feinstein, Kennedy, Leahy and the other members of the left wing of the Democratic party behaving any way other than reprehensibly through this process. In fact, the Democrats will probably become even more aggressive against Judge Roberts for this same reason...they know that another conservative nomination is coming down the pike.

Supporters of the President have tried to remind the public of Republican support for Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg despite their substantial disagreement with her positions and her refusal to answer many questions before the Senate.

But don't expect this properly Constitutional behavior to be followed by the Democrats. Their funding for future elections (and make no mistake, this is the most important consideration in a politican's life) is dependent on pandering to America's most left-wing activists.

(I am not saying that Republicans don't make similar calculations, yet time after time Republican behavior seems at least slightly more based in a principled view of limited government whereas Democratic behavior is as cynical as one could imagine of American politicians.)

While we mourn the passing of one of the great jurists in the history of our country, we should be strapping ourselves in for an intense political roller-coaster ride as we move through the unusual process of filling two Supreme Court vacancies.

[This article also posted at Blogger News Network.]

  • Lucy Stern
    Comment from: Lucy Stern
    09/03/05 @ 11:45:21 pm

    I didn't even know he had passed away. I haven't watched any news today. This should be interesting!

  • Prez-ee-dent Busch
    Comment from: Prez-ee-dent Busch
    09/04/05 @ 12:08:32 am

    Ann Coulter for Chief Justice!

  • Hucbald
    Comment from: Hucbald
    09/04/05 @ 12:22:19 am

    I am seldom moved to pray for the departed, but for reasons known only to God, I was moved to pray for the Honorable Chief Justice's spirit tonight. I figure he must have been as good a guy as I always thought he was.

    Unfortunately, I fear you are correct in your predictions for the upcoming nomination processes: As soon as I think the left cannot possibly become any more unhinged, they move the door farther from the frame.

Comments are closed for this post.
Trackback address for this post
This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots.
Please enter the characters from the image above. (case insensitive)
  • Michelle Malkin
    Trackback from: Michelle Malkin
    09/03/05 @ 11:23:16 pm

    WILLIAM H. REHNQUIST, R.I.P.
    Via Breitbart.com, Chief Justice Rehnquist Dies at Home. Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist died Saturday evening at his home in suburban Virginia, said Supreme Court spokeswoman Kathy Arberg. A statement from the spokeswoman said he was surrounded by ...

  • The Southern California Law Blog
    Trackback from: The Southern California Law Blog
    09/04/05 @ 12:38:16 am

    Supreme Court Justice Rehnquist Dies
    The Washington Post reports

    William Hubbs Rehnquist, the 16th chief justice of the United States, died last night at his home in Arlington. He was 80.

    Rehnquist, who had been suffering from thyroid cancer since last October, had managed to lead the ...

  • Cyber-Conservative
    Trackback from: Cyber-Conservative
    09/04/05 @ 08:01:15 am

    Rehnquist's Aftermath
    Since we're talking about aftermaths today, my fellow HCBA blogger Rossputin has some great comments on what to expect in the wake of Chief Justice ...

  • T. Longren
    Trackback from: T. Longren
    09/04/05 @ 12:21:41 pm

    Chief Justice Rehnquist Dies
    Chief Justice William Rehnquist died lastnight at his home in Virginia. He was 80 years old.
    Lots of people think it’s gonna get really ugly for Bush in the coming weeks. I’ve got no doubt it’ll get ugly. He’s got Katrina, ...

  • T. Longren
    Trackback from: T. Longren
    09/04/05 @ 12:32:21 pm

    Chief Justice Rehnquist Dies
    Chief Justice William Rehnquist died lastnight at his home in Virginia. He was 80 years old.
    Lots of people think it’s gonna get really ugly for Bush in the coming weeks. I’ve got no doubt it’ll get ugly. He’s got Katrina, ...

  • No Oil for Pacifists
    Trackback from: No Oil for Pacifists
    09/04/05 @ 05:22:52 pm

    The Court: What Now?
    The death of Chief Justice Rehnquist late Saturday is bad news for America and a minor crisis for the Bush Administration. But, if anything, the Rehnquist vacancy poses an even greater challenge to left-wing Democrats—Roberts could become Chief.