Israel and Hamas

While I never like news of civilian casualties, and particularly wounded or killed children, the news from Gaza seems to show a remarkably low level of such "collateral damage" (less than 20% of deaths, reportedly) given the scale of attack being engaged in by the Israelis and given the fact that many Hamas positions would be in largely civilian locations. Clearly the Israelis have been gathering intelligence on important Hamas command and weapons locations for a long time.

One thing hasn't changed: The uselessness of the UN...and that's being charitable. It's basically the world's leading anti-Semitic organization. Ban Ki-moon talks about levels of violence that are "unacceptable" and that Israel's actions are "excessive". How would he react if someone lobbed rockets at the UN every week?

Barack Obama's silence on the issue is interesting, but as much as I love to criticize him I think he's right to stay out of it. First of all, there's nothing he could do. Second, he's right that there's just one president at a time. Actually, this could be good for Obama if the mini-war ends (even if it ends with a substantial Israeli position in Gaza) before he is sworn in. Hamas needs to be destroyed...and I think Obama actually agrees with that. Still, the entire Palestinian issue is a morass that has bedeviled presidents more or less since the founding of Israel.

I have no idea what will happen, but what I hope is that Israel will effectively destroy Hamas, or at least any military capability they have, successfully proving that Hezbollah's relative success a couple of years ago is the exception, not the rule.

  • Bob Piccard
    Comment from: Bob Piccard
    01/01/09 @ 07:50:53 am

    Ross,
    Whereas I agree with all you say, I just don't think destroying Hamas is a possibility.

    In the early nineties I was in Gaza and I'm telling you, a Palestinian doesn't become a Hamas member just by saying he wants to. Those people have to apply and meet criteria and have their dedication scrutinized and that kind of thing. And the Hamas organizational structure always has people ready to fill gaps. Kill a colonel and a lt. colonel steps into his job.

    But I sure don't have an answer. There are a lot of Israelis who would be glad to cut a deal with Hamas if it meant peace. But short of every Israeli walking into the sea, there's simply no deal to be cut.

    There are probably Gazans who would rather have peaceful life than a constant struggle but those people have to keep their mouths shut in the best of times and it would be suicidal for them to talk negotiation when bombs are falling.

    What a mess.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Log in now!

If you have no account yet, you can register now... (It only takes a few seconds!)