No beer summit for white girl?

The second half of this note is a guest blog post by one of my former Tahoe Trading colleagues who went by the acronym SAT; I thank him for finding the news report and contributing this piece to my site.

(First, in the section in brackets below, a few comments from Rossputin…)

[Ed: SAT’s comment is in reaction to a NY Post story about a male black Columbia University professor who sucker-punched a white female colleague in the face while discussing race relations in a bar.  As an alumnus of Columbia, I renew my often-stated opinion that it is deserving of our scorn and of none of our money.

The police have refused to charge Mr. McIntyre with a hate crime, though they did charge him with assault and harrassment.  And although I oppose the very existence of hate crime laws, I am disgusted by the police’s obviously treating this action differently than they would have if the colors of the assailant and victim had been reversed.  Is it not entirely obvious from the story that McIntyre’s actions were motivated by hatred of white people?

Separately from the so-called justice system, I want to see how hard Columbia will try to protect this racist.  Any reasonable place would fire him immediately. But Columbia represents the worst of America and while I think there’s a decent chance he will lose his job, I think it will take an unnecessarily long time with the forces of political correctness and black cries of victimhood initially getting the better of Columbia’s administration, which is not known for its good judgment to begin with.

FYI, here is an excerpt from a bio of McIntyre from a Columbia University site:

From the mid-1960s to the mid-1970s, Professor McIntyre worked in civil rights and labor organizing in the deep South. His international experience began with travel abroad in 1972 as co-liaison for the first “People to People Friendship Delegation” to the People’s Republic of China and conducted a subsequent study tour in 1979. Other experiences in the international community have included planning studios in Haiti, Jamaica, Puerto Rico, and South Africa. He also served as director of planning for the Harlem Urban Development Corporation from 1989 to 1994 and advisor to the president of Columbia University on community development and the Empowerment Zone.

While not an explicitly racist bio, it is nevertheless a bio of someone who wants nothing to do with whites. To be clear, I don’t have a problem with his wanting to work with, for, or among anyone he chooses.  I do have a problem with him punching a white person almost certainly because she was white, and then not being treated the same way a white guy would have been treated had he sucker-punched a black guy, much less a black woman.

With that preamble, here are SAT’s thoughts, with a philosophical focus that I particularly appreciate…]

Two nights ago in a bar near the Columbia University campus, 59 year old Aftrican American professor Lionel McIntyre sucker-punched a white female university employee in the face, apparently because she wasn’t “…doing enough about ‘white privilege’".  A patron commented that the punch was so loud it was heard in the back of the kitchen over all the usual noise.  We’re left to contemplate how to think about the situation, which is especially difficult absent instruction via teleprompter from ‘Dear Leader’.  Maybe Mr. McIntyre will show up in the White House as a czar of something or other.

A few obvious questions come to mind:  What if a white professor drilled a black girl in the face while ranting about affirmative action?  Would that be a hate crime (whatever that is)?  Would Sharpton and Jesse run over for a bus ride to the bar from the campus? (as Jesse so valiantly did to solve the violence in Chicago).  How about a Riesling summit at the White House?  Or maybe the prof was simply having a “teachable moment” and the receiving end of a cheap shot was what this woman deserved for not completing her ’self criticism’ session for being born white?

The deeper question is this:  Why is what he did wrong?  In the current liberal university climate (surely Columbia qualifies) where absolute truth is scoffed at, why does anyone have the “right” to tell him he was wrong?  Doesn’t he have a right to “happiness"?  Surely he shouldn’t have to be concerned with this young woman’s rights or happiness.  Maybe that emotional release made him happy, or maybe it “worked for him".  Who are we to say violence is not the “proper” way to settle a dispute?  Isn’t that what we allow our children to be spoon fed by the elite “thinkers” of our day, that whatever may be morally acceptable by one person/society/culture MUST be accepted by all in the all holy name of tolerance?

Is sucker punching someone to prove a point always wrong?  Who are you to say it is “always wrong", because in our society “always wrong” cannot exist if absolute truth does not exist.  And if there is no absolute truth, one’s values/morals/ethics are merely a product of his experience, emotion and culture.  So maybe instead of being shocked and not being able to justify why, we should simply applaud his “unique expression” of how he “feels", which nobody has the ‘right’ to say is morally wrong.

  • Nietzschean
    Comment from: Nietzschean
    12/08/09 @ 09:09:39 am

    I agree with everything you wrote. But I want to go one further. Imagine if a white male punched a black woman in the face, in a bar filled with black men, while yelling at her about the injustices of racial preferences? I suspect he wouldn't even have gotten to the punch; he almost certainly would have been confronted threateningly and most likely assaulted as soon as he had shown signs of anger and aggression and an anti-race preferences opinion. Most white men know they're entering a danger zone, which is why most of us laughed when AG Eric Holder called us a "nation of cowards" and chastised us for not engaging in a racial dialogue. An actual dialog is the last thing most blacks want. Back to my main point, why didn't the white men in the bar start pummeling this piece of shit? If the races had been reversed, the white man would either be dead or in a wheelchair. When did we become such pussies?

  • Comment from: Rossputin
    12/08/09 @ 09:16:54 am

    Given the location of the bar, there were probably very few Caucasians there.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Log in now!

If you have no account yet, you can register now... (It only takes a few seconds!)